The rest of the questions…

Here are the rest of the checklist questions, along with their answers.  The text we are referencing is here.

The first half of the checklist is here.

Let’s jump right in, then.

Is the tension built leading into the payoff? If it is hidden, is the reader set up to make the revelation as jarring as possible?

I can see the start of some tension building in there.  It seems buried behind description though.  That can probably be made better

how are you demonstrating character in the scene? Is characterization driving the exposition (goal is to show something about the character) or is exposition driving the character(goal is to show the character’s reaction)?

Character driven exposition, completely.  This scene is all about introducing Mirian, and trying to show her devotion, as well as establish her stakes for staying at the temple.

Is the scene efficient? Does it drive gracefully and fluidly toward its payoff moment or does it mark time needlessly?

Gah.  No, it wanders a bit through description as I mentioned above.

Does the ending transition align with the mission and context of the next scene? Is it consistent with earlier transitions?

For the most part.  The next scene picks up after the worship service has ended, so I think we transition pretty well into the next scene.

Have you avoided redundant or unneeded description?

Umm….   yeah, about that.

OK.  That gets us through the questions.  In addition to the corrections that these questions have prompted, I need to add some other details.  Mirian is about to be given a mission that involves leaving the temple.  This is distressing for her, and I need to plant a few seeds here as to why.  I decided that she is going to be trying to become a prophetess, which also lends credence to her zealotry.  Also, since she was raised at the temple from childhood, she has formed a close bond with Neijen, which serves as a sub-plot motivation later.  Both of those can be hinted at within this text.

Next entry, we will start chopping up this version, and working toward something that will hopefully be much better!

–j–

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “The rest of the questions…

  1. Pam

    I fully expect this Q&A on your future crits of HE. Maybe you could suggest this as new crit form on CC, somehow build these questions into an inline crit template. 🙂
    On a serious note, I’m enjoying your outlining. Now I really feel like I don’t have to read the book (like um…I didn’t get my homework done. Can I copy yours?).
    P

  2. Yup. still nice to read. And I’m glad you’re being so honest with yourself. Still not sure I can do that with my own work 😦 But, still love reading your struggles 😉

  3. Pingback: Next pass: Efficiency and effect | J Andrew Jansen

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s